Reducing Involuntary Churn for Subscription-Based Businesses
.png)
Customer churn poses a critical threat to subscription-based businesses, especially when it stems from failed payments—known as involuntary churn. This form of churn accounts for approximately 50% of customer losses across the industry, causing annual losses of $278 billion across media, fitness, retail, and online gaming. Many businesses attempt to address this issue through payment recovery methods, which are essentially glorified retry logic. However, these methods exacerbate the problem by converting involuntary churn into voluntary churn. If subscribers are unaware that their payment failed and no longer have access to your services, they will be dissatisfied and may cancel their subscription. The hassle of having to re-enter or update payment information can cause customers to just choose to cancel your service. This directly impacts your lifetime customer value (LCV) and overall profitability. Considering the high cost of acquiring a new customer—or even the resources needed to get updated payment information from existing ones—failing to address payment issues intelligently can significantly undermine your business's financial health. This highlights the urgent need for a more intelligent payment solution that truly mitigates customer churn.
The Pitfalls of Retry Logic in Payment Recovery
Payment retries are often the default strategy used by payment service providers (PSPs) to address failed transactions, but this approach is fundamentally flawed. The true focus should be on achieving first-pass approvals—ensuring payments are successful on the initial attempt. Unfortunately, many businesses remain unaware of this issue, assuming that retries and recovery efforts are the best and only available practice among payment service providers.
Top payment recovery providers have little incentive to move away from retry logic because it aligns with their financial interests. They charge fees per retry attempt, creating a steady revenue stream for them from repeated failures. In fact, leading payment recovery providers often take a percentage of the recovered amount—sometimes as high as 40%—further profiting from the cycle of failed payments. This misalignment of incentives means payment recovery providers have little motivation to optimize for first-pass success, leaving subscription businesses vulnerable to increased churn and costs.
Understanding the Causes of Involuntary Churn
Involuntary churn occurs for various reasons, most of which are linked to payment processing issues. Common causes include:
- Expired credit cards: Customers often forget to update their payment information.
- Fraud suspicion: Banks may decline transactions flagged as potentially fraudulent. 60-70% of transactions that are flagged as fraud are actually legitimate.
- Insufficient funds: Customers may temporarily lack the necessary balance.
- Lost or stolen cards: Customers must cancel cards, inadvertently affecting subscriptions.
- Network errors or credit limit exceedance: Payment processing failures beyond customer control.
These issues demonstrate that involuntary churn isn’t about customer dissatisfaction with the service itself but related to payment processing issues.
Best Practices to Prevent Churn
Top-performing subscription companies employ strategies that maximize first-pass payment approval rates, reducing the need for costly recovery efforts. Revolv3’s increases approval rates, ensuring smoother transactions upfront. Here’s how high-performing companies set themselves apart:
- Tracking Customer Lifetime Value (LTV): Businesses that prioritize LTV are 8.2 times more likely to link this metric directly to revenue objectives. Yet, shockingly, only 8.5% of subscription businesses regularly monitor LTV, missing opportunities to align customer retention efforts with long-term profitability.
- Minimizing Reliance on Payment Recovery Tools: While payment recovery is sometimes necessary, it’s costly and doesn’t always retain customers lost due to failed payments—54% of customers are not recovered even with dedicated efforts. Effective solutions, like those from Revolv3, focus on maximizing approvals on the first attempt, reducing the need for retries and recovery processes.
- Comprehensive Tracking of Payment Failures: Measuring the impact of payment failures is crucial to reducing involuntary churn. Despite its importance, only 53% of businesses track failed payment metrics. Comprehensive tracking allows companies to diagnose patterns and address root causes more proactively.
Dynamic Routing: A Smarter Approach
To tackle involuntary churn, subscription businesses need advanced payment solutions that go beyond retry logic. One of the most effective strategies is dynamic routing, which intelligently directs payment transactions through multiple banking networks and payment processors to maximize the chances of successful authorization.
Benefits of Dynamic Routing:
- IncreasedApproval Rates: Payments are routed through the most efficient route for that specific data to follow, reducing payment failures.
- Reduced Operational Costs: Many payment processors, billing platforms, and gateway providers charge you a fee every time you attempt to process a payment, regardless of whether it’s approved or declined. Dynamic routing reduces decline rates, ultimately reducing your operational costs.
- Enhanced Customer Experience: Ensuring customers remain unaware of payment issues guarantees uninterrupted service and higher satisfaction levels. Payment delays (high latency) can frustrate customers, leading them to abandon their orders. Similarly, incorrect card declines can prompt cancellations. When the payment process is fast and seamless, false declines decrease, leading to better customer experiences and increased revenue, conversions, and retention.
Turn To a Payment Optimization Platform You Can Trust
Involuntary churn is a silent but formidable threat to subscription businesses, often converting into voluntary churn if not handled correctly. The key to mitigating this issue lies in adopting intelligent, dynamic payment solutions. By leveraging advanced SaaS payment platforms and dynamic routing, businesses can reduce failed payments, improve customer satisfaction, and protect their bottom line.
To improve your customer retention, look no further than Revolv3. Revolv3 is a payment optimization platform that can help your business manage subscription billing. With features like dynamic routing and the ability to scale, your business can grow confidently while getting the highest approval rates.
To see how your business can improve your revenues and retain more clients, set up a demo with us.
Customer churn poses a critical threat to subscription-based businesses, especially when it stems from failed payments—known as involuntary churn. This form of churn accounts for approximately 50% of customer losses across the industry, causing annual losses of $278 billion across media, fitness, retail, and online gaming. Many businesses attempt to address this issue through payment recovery methods, which are essentially glorified retry logic. However, these methods exacerbate the problem by converting involuntary churn into voluntary churn. If subscribers are unaware that their payment failed and no longer have access to your services, they will be dissatisfied and may cancel their subscription. The hassle of having to re-enter or update payment information can cause customers to just choose to cancel your service. This directly impacts your lifetime customer value (LCV) and overall profitability. Considering the high cost of acquiring a new customer—or even the resources needed to get updated payment information from existing ones—failing to address payment issues intelligently can significantly undermine your business's financial health. This highlights the urgent need for a more intelligent payment solution that truly mitigates customer churn.
The Pitfalls of Retry Logic in Payment Recovery
Payment retries are often the default strategy used by payment service providers (PSPs) to address failed transactions, but this approach is fundamentally flawed. The true focus should be on achieving first-pass approvals—ensuring payments are successful on the initial attempt. Unfortunately, many businesses remain unaware of this issue, assuming that retries and recovery efforts are the best and only available practice among payment service providers.
Top payment recovery providers have little incentive to move away from retry logic because it aligns with their financial interests. They charge fees per retry attempt, creating a steady revenue stream for them from repeated failures. In fact, leading payment recovery providers often take a percentage of the recovered amount—sometimes as high as 40%—further profiting from the cycle of failed payments. This misalignment of incentives means payment recovery providers have little motivation to optimize for first-pass success, leaving subscription businesses vulnerable to increased churn and costs.
Understanding the Causes of Involuntary Churn
Involuntary churn occurs for various reasons, most of which are linked to payment processing issues. Common causes include:
- Expired credit cards: Customers often forget to update their payment information.
- Fraud suspicion: Banks may decline transactions flagged as potentially fraudulent. 60-70% of transactions that are flagged as fraud are actually legitimate.
- Insufficient funds: Customers may temporarily lack the necessary balance.
- Lost or stolen cards: Customers must cancel cards, inadvertently affecting subscriptions.
- Network errors or credit limit exceedance: Payment processing failures beyond customer control.
These issues demonstrate that involuntary churn isn’t about customer dissatisfaction with the service itself but related to payment processing issues.
Best Practices to Prevent Churn
Top-performing subscription companies employ strategies that maximize first-pass payment approval rates, reducing the need for costly recovery efforts. Revolv3’s increases approval rates, ensuring smoother transactions upfront. Here’s how high-performing companies set themselves apart:
- Tracking Customer Lifetime Value (LTV): Businesses that prioritize LTV are 8.2 times more likely to link this metric directly to revenue objectives. Yet, shockingly, only 8.5% of subscription businesses regularly monitor LTV, missing opportunities to align customer retention efforts with long-term profitability.
- Minimizing Reliance on Payment Recovery Tools: While payment recovery is sometimes necessary, it’s costly and doesn’t always retain customers lost due to failed payments—54% of customers are not recovered even with dedicated efforts. Effective solutions, like those from Revolv3, focus on maximizing approvals on the first attempt, reducing the need for retries and recovery processes.
- Comprehensive Tracking of Payment Failures: Measuring the impact of payment failures is crucial to reducing involuntary churn. Despite its importance, only 53% of businesses track failed payment metrics. Comprehensive tracking allows companies to diagnose patterns and address root causes more proactively.
Dynamic Routing: A Smarter Approach
To tackle involuntary churn, subscription businesses need advanced payment solutions that go beyond retry logic. One of the most effective strategies is dynamic routing, which intelligently directs payment transactions through multiple banking networks and payment processors to maximize the chances of successful authorization.
Benefits of Dynamic Routing:
- IncreasedApproval Rates: Payments are routed through the most efficient route for that specific data to follow, reducing payment failures.
- Reduced Operational Costs: Many payment processors, billing platforms, and gateway providers charge you a fee every time you attempt to process a payment, regardless of whether it’s approved or declined. Dynamic routing reduces decline rates, ultimately reducing your operational costs.
- Enhanced Customer Experience: Ensuring customers remain unaware of payment issues guarantees uninterrupted service and higher satisfaction levels. Payment delays (high latency) can frustrate customers, leading them to abandon their orders. Similarly, incorrect card declines can prompt cancellations. When the payment process is fast and seamless, false declines decrease, leading to better customer experiences and increased revenue, conversions, and retention.
Turn To a Payment Optimization Platform You Can Trust
Involuntary churn is a silent but formidable threat to subscription businesses, often converting into voluntary churn if not handled correctly. The key to mitigating this issue lies in adopting intelligent, dynamic payment solutions. By leveraging advanced SaaS payment platforms and dynamic routing, businesses can reduce failed payments, improve customer satisfaction, and protect their bottom line.
To improve your customer retention, look no further than Revolv3. Revolv3 is a payment optimization platform that can help your business manage subscription billing. With features like dynamic routing and the ability to scale, your business can grow confidently while getting the highest approval rates.
To see how your business can improve your revenues and retain more clients, set up a demo with us.
This article was first published here:
Don't miss an article
Sign up today to receive exciting updates and the latest newsletter from Revolv3.
Get full access to our platform to see how easy it is to configure and manage payments that are optimized for First Pass
